Melissa McGhee, 21 from Tampa, Florida, goes home. I really liked her raspy voice, but… forgetting Stevie’s lyrics twice?

The big surprise of the evening, of course, were the other two contestants in the bottom three: Ace and Lisa. Everyone- including me- expected to see Kevin and Kellie up there. Maybe even Bucky. But Ace and his bedroom eyes? Lisa and her stage confidence? What’s happening, America?